Source Sync

Have you ever hired someone only to realise they weren't the right fit? It’s frustrating, isn’t it?

Whether they didn’t have the skills they claimed or just didn’t gel with the team, a misstep in hiring can be costly. That’s why learning how to vet candidates like a pro is crucial.

In this guide, we’ll walk through everything you need to know about vetting candidates thoroughly.

From preparation to tools, red flags to avoid, and final decision making, you’ll gain practical insights to hire the best talent confidently.

Understanding candidate vetting

Vetting candidates means evaluating them beyond their CV to determine if they are truly the right fit for the role and your organisation. It’s not just about verifying skills but also assessing cultural compatibility and growth potential.

Many hiring managers make the mistake of relying too heavily on CVs. But what someone puts on paper may not tell the full story. Vetting like a pro means digging deeper to uncover the candidate’s real strengths, weaknesses and potential red flags.

Preparing for the vetting process

Define job requirements clearly

Before you start reviewing applications, know exactly what you’re looking for. Create a detailed job description highlighting required skills, experience and attributes. List your “must-haves” and “nice to haves” to make the evaluation process smoother.

Set up a vetting framework

A structured process helps you stay consistent. Outline the stages of vetting, from initial screenings to final interviews, and set timelines for each. Using a scoring system can also ensure objectivity when comparing candidates.

Build a strong hiring team

Vetting isn’t a solo job. Involve HR, team leaders, and even future colleagues. This ensures a holistic evaluation and increases the chances of finding a candidate who fits well.

Tools and techniques for vetting candidates

Screen CVs effectively

Look beyond buzzwords. Pay attention to how candidates describe their accomplishments. Spot potential red flags like gaps in employment or overly vague job descriptions.

Conduct phone screens

A quick phone interview can save time by narrowing down candidates. Ask about their motivations, career goals and basic qualifications. Keep it conversational but focused.

Use behavioural interviews

Instead of hypothetical questions, ask candidates about real situations they’ve handled. For example, “Can you describe a time when you managed a challenging project?” The STAR method - Situation, Task, Action, Result, can help candidates structure their answers.

Incorporate skill assessments

Practical tests can reveal more than interviews. Depending on the role, you might use writing samples, coding challenges, or mock sales calls to evaluate real world abilities.

Check references thoroughly

Reach out to former employers or colleagues to validate the candidate’s claims. Ask specific questions, like their strengths, areas for improvement, and how they handled feedback.

Red flags to watch out for

CV inconsistencies

Mismatched dates, exaggerated roles, or vague descriptions can signal a lack of honesty.

Poor communication

Pay attention to how candidates respond to emails or calls. Unclear or delayed responses can hint at potential issues.

Negative feedback from references

If a former employer hesitates to recommend a candidate, dig deeper to understand why.

Check our other guide to understand and steer clear of these interview mistakes that could cost you the job.

Ensuring a bias free process

Understand implicit bias

Unconscious biases can cloud judgement. Be aware of common biases, like favouring candidates with similar backgrounds or those who seem more confident.

Use structured interviews

By asking the same set of questions to every candidate, you can minimise bias and ensure a fair comparison.

Consider blind CV reviews

Removing personal details like names and photos from resumes can help focus on skills and experience.

See our other guide - Common recruitment mistakes

Leveraging technology for smarter hiring

Try AI powered tools

Platforms like HireVue or LinkedIn Talent Insights can help analyse applications and streamline the vetting process.

Use applicant tracking systems

ATS software can organise applications, highlight top candidates, and track progress across vetting stages.

Embrace video interviews

For remote hiring, video tools like Zoom or Microsoft Teams can be invaluable. They also let you record interviews for later review.

Making the final decision

Compare top candidates
Lay out the strengths and weaknesses of your top choices. Consider how their skills align with the role and the team’s needs.

Involve the team
Get input from everyone involved in the vetting process. A collaborative approach ensures you’re not overlooking important perspectives.

Communicate clearly
Inform unsuccessful candidates with thoughtful feedback. For the selected candidate, make an enticing offer that reflects their value.

Final thoughts

Hiring the right candidate doesn’t have to feel like a gamble. By following a structured process, using the right tools, and staying mindful of potential biases, you can make more confident hiring decisions.

Remember, vetting isn’t about finding perfection - it’s about finding the best fit for your team. With these strategies, you’re well on your way to vetting candidates like a true professional.

Are you ready to elevate your hiring process and secure the best candidates for your organisation? Partner Source Sync today and experience a streamlined and thorough evaluation of potential hires.

Useful resources

How to Vet Candidates: Creating a Vetting Process for Employment. (2019). Glassdoor.com.

Arfa Farheen